AT&T working with 4 open access fiber companies including Ubiquity in Minnesota

Last week, I reported that Verizon was acquiring Frontier. This week, according to Broadband Breakfast, AT&T is working with four open access fiber companies, including Ubiquity in Minnesota…

AT&T announced on Monday wholesale agreements with four open access fiber broadband providers. That’s in addition to the company’s existing partnership on an open access network with investment firm BlackRock.

“Each company AT&T is working with was selected because they provide opportunities to expand AT&T Fiber distribution to new service areas without existing fiber options,” the company wrote in a release. “As these providers add fiber locations, AT&T will evaluate where it wants to offer AT&T Fiber.”

Those companies are Boldyn Networks, Digital Infrastructure Group, PRIME FiBER, and Uniquity. Initial build areas include multiple Texas military bases by Boldyn, PRIME in Florida, and Ubiquity in Minnesota. AT&T didn’t specify the size of those projects but said it’s on track to surpass its goal of 30 million passings by the end of next year, potentially by as much as 15 million.

Verizon to acquire Frontier

Verizon reports...

Verizon Communications Inc. (NYSE, NASDAQ: VZ) and Frontier Communications Parent, Inc. (NASDAQ: FYBR) today announced they have entered into a definitive agreement for Verizon to acquire Frontier in an all-cash transaction valued at $20 billion. This strategic acquisition of the largest pure-play fiber internet provider in the U.S. will significantly expand Verizon’s fiber footprint across the nation, accelerating the company’s delivery of premium mobility and broadband services to current and new customers. It will also expand Verizon’s intelligent edge network for digital innovations like AI and IoT.

The combination will integrate Frontier’s cutting-edge fiber network into Verizon’s leading portfolio of fiber and wireless assets, including its best-in-class Fios offering. Over approximately four years, Frontier has invested $4.1 billion upgrading and expanding its fiber network, and now derives more than 50% of its revenue from fiber products. Frontier’s 2.2 million fiber subscribers across 25 states will join Verizon’s approximately 7.4 million Fios connections1 in 9 states and Washington, D.C. In addition to Frontier’s 7.2 million fiber locations, the company is committed to its plan to build out an additional 2.8 million fiber locations by the end of 2026.

Will your county be eligible for the $9 million in the FCC 5G Plan for Rural America subsidies?

Doug Dawson is a very smart guy. He recently wrote about the 5G Plan for Rural America and how counties without adequate 5G could prepare for it…

The FCC announced it will move forward with the 5G Plan for Rural America. This new subsidy will provide $9 billion to improve rural cellular coverage. I know in working throughout rural America that poor cellular coverage is often a worse problem that broadband coverage.

The FCC is convinced that the current cellular coverage maps are adequate to define the areas that deserve the new subsidy. In the counties I’ve been working in this does not seem to be the case, and the FCC cellular maps often seem to be overstating speed, similar to broadband speed claims. This was bolstered by a recent letter to the FCC from the Rural Wireless Association that claims that the FCC cellular maps are poor.

Since the FCC seems determined to move forward with the current maps and seems to be on a fast track to initiate the 5G plan,  there should be a sense of urgency in any County that thinks it needs better cellular coverage. The following steps should be considered immediately because it is possible that the FCC could launch the new 5G Fund by the end of the year.

First is to look at the FCC cellular map. This is part of the same map system used to show broadband coverage. Type in any address in a county, and a detailed map will appear. Choose the Mobile Broadband button at the top and you’ll be able to see the claimed cellular coverage at any address. The 5G Fund will bring better cellular coverage to locations where there is no 5G today (just 4G LTE) or where 5G speeds are claimed to be slower than 7/1 Mbps. You can look at the parts of your county where you believe cellular coverage is poor and see if the FCC map agrees with your local knowledge.

The 5G Fund subsidy will only be awarded to areas where the FCC map shows that no carrier is offering 5G with speeds of at least 7/1 Mbps. If even only one carrier meets that criteria, the area will not get funding. You might see some cellular carriers you don’t recognize in the FCC map like Project Genesis (which is Dish) or local cellular carriers.

A next step might be to dash off quick comments to the FCC about the 5G Fund timeline. Surprisingly, the FCC is not planning to have a map challenge period for counties to contest the cellular map coverage. Comments are due to the FCC by September 10. If nothing else, tell the FCC they should include some time for a map challenge. The FCC has been talking about launching this fund for four years, and it seems irresponsible to suddenly rush without giving local governments a chance to verify and challenge the FCC cellular maps.

There was a comment made in this docket that said local governments have had plenty of time to dispute the maps since the new FCC maps have been out for several years. However, all of the counties I have been working with have been concentrating on the FCC broadband maps. Almost nobody has looked hard at claimed cellular speeds – until this order came out, nobody knew what to look for on the maps. Making a comment in an FCC docket is relatively easy to do. The first thing on the form is to ask for the proceeding, which in this case is 20-32 Establishing a 5G Fund for Rural America.

Finally, if the FCC maps overstate cellular coverage in your area you need to get folks out taking cellular speed tests using the FCC app in the areas where you think coverage is poor. To be of any use for the 5G Fund the speed tests probably need to be done this month.

Speed tests can only be done using the FCC’s own speed test app. The app is available at the Google Play Store or Apple App store. Speed tests only count if they area taken outside or in a moving vehicle – indoor tests or tests on a WiFi network don’t county. For the 5G Fund, you want to take speed tests from a stationary point, which means pulling over on the side of the road. Tests must be taken between 6:00 AM and 10:00 PM.

FCC to move forward with 5G funds to target investments in rural communities

The FCC reports

The Federal Communications Commission today announced it had adopted new rules to move forward with targeted investments in the deployment of advanced, 5G mobile wireless broadband services in rural communities.  The bipartisan vote on these rules reignites the 5G Fund for Rural America using the FCC’s new and improved broadband coverage map, which shows that millions of homes and businesses lack mobile 5G coverage.

“With the progress we’ve made in mapping broadband service availability, there is no reason to wait to put the 5G Fund to work connecting households and businesses in rural communities across the country,” said Chairwoman Rosenworcel.  “We are ready to use every tool available to make sure that those who live, work, and travel in rural America have access to advanced, 5G mobile wireless broadband services.”

For Phase I of the 5G Fund, the Commission will use a multi-round reverse auction to distribute up to $9 billion to bring voice and 5G mobile broadband service to rural areas of the country unlikely to otherwise see unsubsidized deployment of 5G-capable networks.  Once the Commission is ready, we will announce the expected start of the auction through a Public Notice.

The 5G Fund Phase I auction will rely on the mobile coverage data obtained in the Broadband Data Collection – including through the FCC’s Mobile Speed Test app – and reflected on the FCC’s National Broadband Map.  In 2021, Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel established a Task Force dedicated to implementing long-overdue improvements to the agency’s broadband data and mapping tools.  The Task Force continues to gather data and update the maps to ensure that programs like the 5G Fund effectively target its resources.

Additionally, to promote the deployment of Open Radio Access Network technology (Open RAN) and its benefits for competition, national security, and supply chain reliability, the 5G Fund now includes up to $900 million in incentives for incorporating Open RAN in 5G Fund-supported networks.

This Second Report and Order, adopted by a full vote of the Commission, also modifies the definition of areas eligible for 5G Fund Phase I support and ensures that areas in Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands that meet the new definition will be included in the auction.  The item increases the overall budget for Phase I of the 5G Fund to up to $9 billion and proportionally increases the Tribal reserve budget—a set-aside portion of the fund to support connecting Tribal communities.  The rules also require that recipients of 5G Fund support implement cybersecurity and supply chain risk management plans.

Arvig and BEVCOMM ask the FCC to look into classification of Midcontinent

Broadband Breakfast reports…

The Minnesota companies said a local competitor does not offer voice service.

A federal agency is planning to take a close look at whether two broadband providers deserve millions more dollars in future support after what they say was a flawed allocation process.

The Federal Communications Commission is seeking input on claims that two Midwest broadband providers saw lower Enhanced ACAM support because a competitor was misclassified.

Here’s more info on the claim from the FCC Public Notice of comment… (Comments due September 13)

By this Public Notice, the Wireline Competition Bureau (Bureau) seeks comment on the filing submitted by Arvig Enterprises, Inc. (Arvig) and Rural Communications Holding Corporation (BEVCOMM),[1] which claimed that those companies’ Enhanced Alternative Connect America Cost Model (Enhanced A-CAM) support offers were incorrectly calculated because Midcontinent Communications (Midco) was incorrectly classified as an unsubsidized competitor offering voice service.[2]

[1] Comments of Arvig Enterprises, Inc. (Arvig) and Rural Communications Holding Corporation (BEVCOMM), WC Docket No. 10-90 (filed Jul. 16, 2024) (Arvig Comments).

[2] Id. at 2.

Ely MN is left with unreliable cell coverage after fiber circuit issues

The Ely Echo posts an opinion piece after being without reliable cell coverage for days…

A cellular outage that wiped out Verizon and made AT&T difficult to use appears to have been caused by a disruption in a fiber circuit between Ely and planet Earth. This has made for a difficult week as the outage started around 4 p.m. Monday and stretched into Thursday afternoon.

While sending text messages, checking Facebook, or uploading Snapchat videos may not be the most important losses, not being able to call for help should rank at the top of the priority list.

We pride ourselves on living at the end of the road. But being at the end of the fiber line sucks. We’ve been without proper services for over 72 hours with little or no communication from communication companies.

Public safety officials get all excited when you can’t dial 911 to an outage. Not being able to dial anyone is a bit bigger deal, yet we’ve heard nothing from them or any elected officials.

The only person who has been providing updates with any authenticity has been Isaac Olson of Treehouse Broadband. He posted the following on Thursday afternoon: “Cellular Outage in Ely Area: “On August 6th, we noticed our fiber circuit through Consolidated go offline (luckily we have a backup). At the same time, Verizon and AT&T service in the area went to limited/no connection.

Big companies don’t really concern themselves with us little old folks at the end of the road. We’re nothing more than a minuscule bump on a profit and loss statement. Treehouse Broadband is locally owned and operated and they truly care about their customers and the service provided.

FCC Launches New Mobile Speed Test App

Broadband Breakfast reports on a new speed test for *mobile* connections. (I had to read it three times before I caught the word mobile.)…

The Federal Communications Commission announced on Tuesday a new Mobile Speed Test app to help users easily challenge provider-reported mobile coverage data, replacing the original FCC Speed Test app.

While the original app allowed consumers to test their mobile and in-home broadband performance, the new app ensures accurate provider-reported mobile coverage data with features such as “Repeated Test” for hands-free testing, displays an in-app map of where a test was taken and the ability to review speed test results on the National Broadband Map.

T-Mobile to buy USCellular – might help rural areas

Broadband Breakfast reports

T-Mobile announced on Tuesday the company agreed to buy UScellular’s wireless operations and nearly a third of its spectrum holdings for $4.4 billion.

T-Mobile will add more than 4 million customers to its postpaid phone footprint, which stood at 76.5 million as of the company’s first quarter earnings report. T-Mobile will also scoop up spectrum in the 24 gigahertz, 2.5 GHz, 600 and 700 MHz, AWS, and PCS bands.

There seems to be interest in rural areas…

UScellular will also hold on to its nearly 4,400 towers. As part of the deal, T-Mobile will enter 15-year lease agreements on at least 2,015 of those towers and extend leases on the 600 towers where the company is already a tenant.

Therivel said large national carriers expanding into rural areas, which make up nearly 40 percent of U.S. Cellular’s footprint, and the ballooning costs of 5G spectrum and network equipment presented barriers for the company.

“Large national players have expanded into rural America. That creates significant competition, where previously there might have been only a few players,” he said. “Delivering on our mission requires a level of scale that is best achieved by combining our wireless operations with a national player.”

UScellular customers will be able to stay on their current plan or switch to an unlimited T-Mobile plan with no switching costs, Therivel said.

Solar storms bring beautiful Northern Lights in MN but disrupt precision agriculture

While most of us were gleefully chasing down the Northern Lights last weekend, the New York Times (via Yahoo News) reports on another side…

The powerful geomagnetic storm that cast the northern lights’ vivid colors across the Northern Hemisphere over the weekend also caused some navigational systems in tractors and other farming equipment to break down at the height of planting season, suppliers and farmers said.

Many farmers have come to rely on the equipment, which uses GPS and other navigational technology and helps them to plant more efficiently and precisely by keeping rows straight and avoiding gaps or overlap. But over the weekend, some of those operations in the Midwest, as well as in other parts of the United States and Canada, temporarily ground to a halt.

In Minnesota, some farmers who had planned to spend Friday night sowing seeds were hamstrung by the outages. “I’ve never dealt with anything like this,” said Patrick O’Connor, owner of a farm about 80 miles south of Minneapolis that mainly grows corn and soybean.

O’Connor said that after being rained out for two weeks, he got into his tractor around 5 p.m., hoping to spend the night planting corn. When he received a warning about his GPS system, he called a technical help line and was directed to a message saying there was an outage and nothing could be done to fix it.

Ag Web talked about what it means for farmers…

It’s all happening right as farmers are rushing to get the 2024 crop planted.

“The good news is those radio blackouts for GPS may only last for a few hours or half a day,” says Dr. Terry Griffin a Professor & Cropping Systems Economist at Kansas State University. “My message is: if this is a radio blackout then patience is your best bet. Go check the NOAA website and if the planetary K-Index is red instead of green then go have an early lunch.”

Beyond the inconvenience of delayed field work, there could be real dollars lost to such an extended outage.

From an agricultural perspective, Dr. Griffin has been studying the economic impacts of GPS outages for several years. He’s found that even a few hours to half a day of lost GPS signal can come with a cost for farmers. That’s especially true for farmers who miss an optimum planting or harvesting window. Pushing field work later into the season can ultimately cost them yield and performance during the season.

“There are there are some real penalties and real dollars that come into effect when we’re not able to do field work,” Dr. Griffin said.

That said, it depends on the time of year and the regions impacted. A January disruption would likely have less impact than one during planting or harvest.

Dr. Griffin says while GPS satellites have been in use and in orbit for many years – the first launched in 1978 – civilian use of GPS is relatively new.
He believes these new space weather events will come with a learning curve.

“This was the first solar cycle maximum we’ve had that’s going to be big with satellite communications,” Dr. Griffin said. “So, we’re going to find out some things.”

It’s not yet archived but an hour ago, I heard on MPR an interview with the MN farmer from the NY Times article. He talked about how it isn’t just a matter of using the GPS to make sure the rows in the field are straight. The GPS helps keep track of the soil quality, historical needs of the plants and more and distributes seeds and nutrients based location. So it made sense to wait until the solar storm was over rather than forge ahead using “tradition” sowing practices.

Also when asked if he thought this might happen again, the farmer said yes – if it’s happened once, it will likely happen again.

Interesting both in terms of the things the engineers and scientists need to learn about all aspects of precision agriculture and the value that the farmers put on using precision ag tools!

 

 

 

Turns out seniors are pretty tech savvy and will want broadband

Connectivity Trends for Senior Living in the United States (2024-2029), a report by Maravedit, reports…

The U.S. population continues to age rapidly, and this aging boom has a multifold impact on the senior housing industry. Baby Boomers make up an increasingly large share of the senior population and they are living longer and healthier lives than the generations before them. After the heavy drop experienced during the pandemic, senior housing occupancy rates are back to healthier levels. The National Investment Center estimates over 600,000
additional units will be needed by 2029 to maintain the current penetration rate.
Contrary to popular belief, seniors have become increasingly technology-savvy and are enthusiastic internet users. While senior residents continue to consume mainly
linear/cable television, online streaming is on the rise. Seniors also increasingly use mobile applications for banking, video chatting, gaming and engaging with their local community.
As active seniors move around their apartments and common areas, Wi-Fi roaming becomes important to maintain connectivity throughout the property, whether it be independent or assisted living. In short, senior residents’ expectations are rapidly changing.
The senior living industry has its share of challenges. It is marked by staff shortages, increased medical costs and low digitalization. The staff shortages create a domino effect,
leading to an overly taxed workforce and an increase in labor costs. Senior housing leaders are continuously asked to do more with less. This state of affairs represents an opportunity for technology and connectivity to play a vital role in improving operational efficiency through automation and better integration of legacy systems and facility IoT.
For caregivers and administrative staff, managed Wi-Fi is the foundational layer that enables them to serve the residents and better accomplish their duties. Wi-Fi makes it
possible to reduce residents’ isolation while facilitating the staff’s work in senior living.
Video calls, telemedicine, home automation systems — the list of innovations that improve the well-being of senior residents while optimizing the working conditions of care staff is growing.
On March 5, 2024, during the production of this report, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) made a statement that may negatively impact bulk-managed Wi-Fi.
This is causing concern and uncertainty among the stakeholders, but it is too early to know the impact.
No matter what the FCC decides, it only makes sense for property operators to invest in a better connectivity experience for their residents and outsource their IT operations and WiFi to specialized managed service providers. We remain bullish that we are only at the
dawn of this emerging sector.

Is AI a golden goose for mobile broadband providers?

So much is happening in the world of broadband these days – most of it related to the federal funding (IIJA/BEAD) coming into the states. Yet inherent in the funding are moments of waiting as the NTIA gets back to States at various parts of the application process. These are times when I think it’s helpful to step back and think broadly about what’s about to happen with this huge investment. The article from Light Reading on AI (artificial intelligence) and mobile broadband providers caught my eye…

During America’s Gilded Age, a handful of scrappy entrepreneurs built the nation’s railway system and in the process created huge piles of money by controlling shipping and travel lanes across the country.

Today, as AI hype begins consuming everything in sight, some are hinting that mobile network operators – and their equipment vendors – may be sitting in a similar position thanks to the data they own.

After all, AI models are only as good as the data they’re trained on. That’s why Google is reportedly paying Reddit $60 million every year.

And the telecom industry has an enormous amount of data.

“I think it’s extremely valuable,” said Jonathan Davidson, in discussing the amount of data owned by telecom companies. Davidson is the EVP and GM of Cisco Networking, and he made his comments during a media event here on the sidelines of the MWC Barcelona trade show. “We are doing billions of [network] measurements every single day… We have a view into all of these networks that no one else has.”

 

OPPORTUNITY: FCC seeks public comment on broadband data collection challenge process

The FCC is seeking public comment on broadband data collection challenge process…

Comment Date: February 19, 2024

Reply Comment Date: March 5, 2024

 By this Public Notice, the Broadband Data Task Force, in coordination with the Wireless Telecommunications Bureau (WTB), Wireline Competition Bureau, and Office of Economics and Analytics (OEA) (collectively BDTF), seeks public comment on its Broadband Data Collection (BDC) challenge processes.  The BDC is the most granular, detailed collection of broadband availability data the FCC has ever gathered or released, depicting location-level information on mass-market fixed broadband internet access services available across the United States as well as standardized coverage maps of 3G, 4G, and 5G mobile wireless services.  Importantly, the BDC—for the first time ever—also provides opportunities for consumers, State, local, and Tribal governmental entities, and other stakeholders to challenge the coverage and broadband availability information reported to the FCC and depicted in the new maps.

Pursuant to section 802(b)(5)(D) of the Communications Act, as amended by Pub. L. No. 116-130, the Commission is required to submit a report to Congress that evaluates the challenge processes and considers whether the Commission should commence an inquiry on the need for other tools to help identify potential inaccuracies in BDC data and improve the accuracy of those data.[1]  Comments received in response to this Public Notice will inform this report.  To this end, we request input on the extent to which stakeholders are participating in the challenge processes, whether they find the challenge processes to be “user-friendly”, and, if not, what improvements the Commission can make to its processes to make participation more user-friendly, and the effectiveness of the challenge processes in improving the quality and accuracy of our broadband availability data.

[1] See 47 U.S.C. § 642(b)(5)(D);  Broadband Deployment Accuracy and Technological Availability Act, Pub. L. No. 116-130, 134 Stat. 228 (2020) (codified at 47 U.S.C. §§ 641-646) (Broadband DATA Act or BDA), 47 U.S.C. § 642(a)(1)(A).  The report must be submitted to the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation and the House of Representatives Committee on Energy and Commerce.  47 U.S.C. § 642(b)(5)(D).

Farmington MN is getting free WiFi in the city parks (Dakota County)

The Minneapolis Star Tribune reports

Most of Farmington’s city parks will have free Wi-Fi once Hiawatha Broadband Communications finishes building its fiber optic network infrastructure across the city, according to Mayor Joshua Hoyt.

Hiawatha Broadband began building the network in April; once it is complete, residents can choose the company as their internet provider. The company plans to bring Wi-Fi access to 20 of the city’s 29 parks by 2025.

The parks were chosen based on factors like foot traffic, size, cost, amenities and frequency of vandalism, said Peter Gilbertson, Farmington’s information technology director.

The city will use about $522,000 in American Rescue Plan Act funds to provide power, poles and security cameras in parks.

Partnering with Hiawatha Broadband “saved the city an incredible amount of money, which will be repurposed to other initiatives,” Gilbertson said.

What is Li-Fi? How is it difference from Wi-Fi? And is it better

In 2016, the MN Broadband Task Force learned about Li-Fi and I haven’t seen much about it since until a recent article in IEEE Spectrum

The recent adoption of IEEE 802.11bb has launched light fidelity, or Li-Fi, which opened the door into an era of wireless communication for advanced Wi-Fi technologies. Li-Fi enables Wi-Fi to use light waves instead of radio waves to transmit and receive data.

IEEE 802.11bb defines the rules for how Li-Fi devices will communicate with each other and how fast they can transfer data. According to the standard, such devices should be able to send and receive data at speeds between 10 megabits per second and 9.6 gigabits per second.

The standard introduces a new realm of fast, reliable wireless communication that promises to revolutionize the way we connect and communicate.

Here are some of the comparisons to Wi-Fi…

Li-Fi enables high-speed wireless connectivity with data rates of up to 100 Mb/s per square meter, making it ideal for densely populated areas, i.e., conference rooms and classrooms. The technology operates in additional unregulated spectrum, where it has no interference with RF-based wireless technologies.

Enhanced security is another advantage, as Li-Fi communication is confined to the physical boundaries of the light signal, such as the inside of a room, making it difficult to intercept.

However, Li-Fi has limitations. Its range is relatively short—typically limited to a few meters in a single room—which means that it requires a dense network of access points for broader coverage.

Additionally, the available bandwidth can be constrained by the capabilities of light sources and detectors. Implementing Li-Fi infrastructure can also be more expensive compared with Wi-Fi.

Because I find it easy to get confused, I’ll point out that this isn’t a way to reach remote locations, it’s a way to make sure everyone at the Vikings game can post on the social media.

Library hotspots a boon to people experiencing homelessness

Colin Rhinesmith recently published a report on how library hotspot checkout programs can support people experiencing homelessness. The report is behind a pay wall but the abstract gets to the gist…

Previous studies have examined the benefits and challenges of using mobile phones to support people experiencing homelessness. However, few studies have considered how mobile Wi-Fi hotspots support unhoused individuals and couples through public library lending programs. This paper seeks to address a gap in mobile communication scholarship by contributing insights from a qualitative study of library patrons who checked out mobile hotspots from the Boston Public Library in Massachusetts, USA. The findings show that although mobile hotspots provided many benefits for public library patrons in general, these devices facilitated mobile communication with a different sense of urgency for six people experiencing homelessness who also happened to be in romantic relationships. More concretely, the study found that mobile Wi-Fi hotspots reduced stress and anxiety for unhoused patrons because without the devices, patrons without fixed residences worried they could not be found; that hotspots kept unhoused patrons more connected, and therefore safer, in their tents despite the cold weather and a lack of electricity; and that unhoused patrons were concerned about their devices getting stolen because of their precarious situation. Although the unhoused patrons who participated in this study also shared their recommendations regarding how mobile hotspot lending programs in public libraries could be improved, they also mentioned that the benefits of hotspot availability far outweighed their challenges. The findings have implications for those working to address homelessness, including community-based organizations, government agencies, and policymakers who seek further insights into the positive role that mobile hotspot devices can play in supporting positive health outcomes for individuals and couples experiencing homelessness.