OPPORTUNITY: FCC seeks public comment on broadband data collection challenge process

The FCC is seeking public comment on broadband data collection challenge process…

Comment Date: February 19, 2024

Reply Comment Date: March 5, 2024

 By this Public Notice, the Broadband Data Task Force, in coordination with the Wireless Telecommunications Bureau (WTB), Wireline Competition Bureau, and Office of Economics and Analytics (OEA) (collectively BDTF), seeks public comment on its Broadband Data Collection (BDC) challenge processes.  The BDC is the most granular, detailed collection of broadband availability data the FCC has ever gathered or released, depicting location-level information on mass-market fixed broadband internet access services available across the United States as well as standardized coverage maps of 3G, 4G, and 5G mobile wireless services.  Importantly, the BDC—for the first time ever—also provides opportunities for consumers, State, local, and Tribal governmental entities, and other stakeholders to challenge the coverage and broadband availability information reported to the FCC and depicted in the new maps.

Pursuant to section 802(b)(5)(D) of the Communications Act, as amended by Pub. L. No. 116-130, the Commission is required to submit a report to Congress that evaluates the challenge processes and considers whether the Commission should commence an inquiry on the need for other tools to help identify potential inaccuracies in BDC data and improve the accuracy of those data.[1]  Comments received in response to this Public Notice will inform this report.  To this end, we request input on the extent to which stakeholders are participating in the challenge processes, whether they find the challenge processes to be “user-friendly”, and, if not, what improvements the Commission can make to its processes to make participation more user-friendly, and the effectiveness of the challenge processes in improving the quality and accuracy of our broadband availability data.

[1] See 47 U.S.C. § 642(b)(5)(D);  Broadband Deployment Accuracy and Technological Availability Act, Pub. L. No. 116-130, 134 Stat. 228 (2020) (codified at 47 U.S.C. §§ 641-646) (Broadband DATA Act or BDA), 47 U.S.C. § 642(a)(1)(A).  The report must be submitted to the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation and the House of Representatives Committee on Energy and Commerce.  47 U.S.C. § 642(b)(5)(D).

FCC says Starlink is ineligible for $900M in RDOF subsidies

Punjab News reports…

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) in the US has announced not to award Elon Musk’s Starlink nearly $900 million subsidy for expanding broadband service in rural areas, based on its failure to meet the basic programme requirements.

The ‘Universal Service Fund’ programme, which uses funding collected from consumers, sought to expand access to broadband networks in rural areas.

“The FCC followed a careful legal, technical and policy review to determine that this applicant (Starlink) had failed to meet its burden to be entitled to nearly $900 million in universal service funds for almost a decade, ” said FCC Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel.

The agency qualified Starlink at the short-form stage, but at the long-form stage, the Commission determined that Starlink failed to demonstrate that it could deliver the promised service.

“Funding these vast proposed networks would not be the best use of limited Universal Service Fund dollars to bring broadband to unserved areas across the US, ” the Commission noted.

And more details from Broadband Communities…

The FCC has reaffirmed a prior decision to reject Starlink’s application to receive public support through the Rural Digital Opportunity Fund program.

The decision was announced by the FCC in the form of a statement, released Dec. 12, which accompanied the release of an Order on Review that resulted in a decision to uphold the denial of Starlink’s application.

FCC Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel’s statements were included in the FCC’s recent announcement. She said the FCC “followed a careful legal, technical and policy review to determine that this applicant had failed to meet its burden to be entitled to nearly $900 million in universal service funds for almost a decade.”

The original decision to deny Starlink’s application was made by the Wireline Bureau in August 2022. At the time, Rosenworcel said Starlink’s technology “has real promise,” but she raised concerns as well.

“The question before us was whether to publicly subsidize (Starlink’s) still developing technology for consumer broadband—which requires that users purchase a $600 dish—with nearly $900 million in universal service funds until 2032,” she previously said in August 2022, according to an FCC announcement about Starlink’s original denial.

Industry response to FCC talking about raising broadband speeds and looking at affordability

The FCC is planning to measure broadband affordability. Ars Technica reports on the cable industry’s lobby group response…

The US broadband industry is protesting a Federal Communications Commission plan to measure the affordability of Internet service.

The FCC has been evaluating US-wide broadband deployment progress on a near-annual basis for almost three decades but hasn’t factored affordability into these regular reviews. The broadband industry is afraid that a thorough examination of prices will lead to more regulation of ISPs. …

Cable industry lobby group NCTA-The Internet & Television Association complained in a filing released Monday that the Notice of Inquiry’s “undue focus on affordability—or pricing—is particularly inappropriate.” The group, which represents cable providers such as Comcast and Charter, said that setting an affordability benchmark could lead to rate regulation:

While the Commission has reiterated that it has no interest in any kind of rate regulation, the proposal to make a traditional deployment analysis contingent on whether the Commission determines that broadband pricing is sufficiently affordable suggests that rate regulation in some form is potentially on the table.

They also remark on industry response to potentially  raising the speed definitions…

The FCC Notice of Inquiry also proposes to raise the speed of its benchmark for determining whether a broadband service counts as “advanced telecommunications capability.” People often refer to this as the FCC’s broadband definition. The benchmark was last updated in January 2015 and remains at 25Mbps downstream and 3Mbps upstream.

Trump-era FCC Chairman Ajit Pai kept the 25Mbps/3Mbps standard throughout his term. The new Notice of Inquiry prepared by Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel proposes raising the standard to 100Mbps on the download side and 20Mbps for uploads. The notice also proposes “a long-term fixed broadband speed goal” of 1Gbps download speeds and 500Mbps upload speeds.

USTelecom, which represents fiber and DSL providers such as AT&T and Verizon, supported the 100Mbps/20Mbps benchmark but objected to the long-term goal of 1Gbps/500Mbps. The trade group argued that the 500Mbps upload benchmark would shut out all non-fiber networks.

FCC denies LTD Broadband’s funding appeal and issues fines. Owner starts/rebrands GigFire?

The Minneapolis Star Tribune reports on LTD Broadband…

The Federal Communications Commission has upheld a decision to block LTD Broadband from using any part of $1.3 billion in federal grants to subsidize the construction of high-speed internet infrastructure, including a major proposed buildout in Minnesota.

The FCC this week denied an appeal from LTD and proposed a nearly $22 million penalty for the embattled telecom company. The agency and many critics in Minnesota say the company is unlikely to deliver on its promises to serve rural areas lacking adequate broadband after winning a grant contest in 2020.

Corey Hauer, CEO of Nevada-based LTD, told the Star Tribune the company is “disappointed in the two FCC decisions and are evaluating our options, including taking the FCC to court.”

They added…

Separately, the FCC also said Hauer created a similar company named GigFire potentially to evade liability for LTD’s actions. The agency hasn’t imposed the penalty yet, but can do so after LTD has a chance to respond.

In March 2023, LTD Broadband announced a name change to GigiFi. I remember the announced predated a new website. (It looks like there is a gigifi based in Puerto Rico.) Now the LTD Broadband website mentions and redirects the visitor to GigFire. It’s unclear to me whether this is a rebranding or a new venture. Both GigFire and LTD Broadband currently show up as vendors on the FCC National Broadband Map. That seems problematic, especially when they seem to cover the same area.

The map below from the FCC National Map shows where GigFire serves FTTH (in pink) and unlicensed fixed wireless (in purple):

And here is the same map for LTD Broadband…

The FCC denies LTD Broadband’s application for review of RDOF awards

LTD Broadband was awarded the opportunity to apply for a lot of federal money (RDOF) to bring broadband to specific states, including Minnesota. They were the largest winning bidder. LTD needed to submit long-form applications to receive the awards. The review of the long form applications was not as success of the original application. LTD Broadband trying to appeal to the negative results and the FCC has just answered by saying they deny the application for review. The full reply is detailed and interesting. I have tried below to pull out the points most pertinent to LTD Broadband…

By this Order on Review, we deny an application for review submitted by LTD Broadband, LLC (LTD).1 LTD seeks review of a decision by the Wireline Competition Bureau (WCB or Bureau) that denied its application to be authorized to receive broadband deployment support from the Rural Digital Opportunity Fund (RDOF) Auction 904.

…

LTD timely submitted a short-form application and was announced as one of 386 bidders approved to participate in Auction 904.22 Auction 904 commenced on October 29, 2020. In the first round of the auction, LTD bid to deploy gigabit service to 2,223,682 locations in 16 states, seeking $13,326,751,930 in 10-year support despite an existing small deployment footprint and subscriber base of approximately 15,000 customers. At the conclusion of the auction after 19 rounds of bidding, LTD was

the largest winning bidder in the auction, with winning bids to deploy gigabit speed low-latency service to 528,088 locations in 15 states with $1,320,920,719 in 10-year support.

…

LTD filed its timely long-form application for support on January 29, 2021, and submitted, among other items, an attachment with its detailed technology and system design description as required of all applicants by February 15, 2021. On February 18, 2021, staff announced that there were 417 long-form applicants.26

…

Auction 904 long-form applicants were required to certify that they are eligible telecommunications carriers (ETCs) in all bid areas and to submit appropriate documentation supporting such certification on or before June 7, 2021.27 LTD timely sought and received ETC designation in eight states (Colorado, Illinois, Indiana, Minnesota, Missouri, Ohio, Texas, and Wisconsin). In the remaining seven states in which it had winning bids (California, Iowa, Kansas, Oklahoma, Nebraska, North Dakota,

South Dakota), LTD filed a request for waiver of the June 7, 2021 deadline to submit ETC certifications to the FCC.28 In two separate orders, the Bureau denied LTD’s request for waiver of the ETC certification deadline for California, Kansas, Oklahoma, Iowa, Nebraska, and North Dakota.29 LTD subsequently defaulted on all winning bids in Kansas and Oklahoma and sought reconsideration of the waiver denials regarding California, Iowa, Nebraska, and North Dakota.30 Later, LTD withdrew its petition for reconsideration of the waiver denials in California and Iowa, thus defaulting on all bids in those two states.31

…

In March 2021, June 2021, September 2021, and multiple times in March 2022, staff spoke with LTD about the financial and technical deficiencies that staff identified in LTD’s long form application. In these calls, staff explained the insufficiencies to LTD and answered LTD’s questions regarding program requirements. LTD did not submit revised financial information after its initial filings at the long-form application deadline. On August 5, 2021, LTD submitted a revised technical description

purporting to cover Arkansas, Louisiana, and Mississippi (states in which it did not place winning bids). Even if assumed to apply to the fifteen states in which LTD did place winning bids, the revised documents did not sufficiently address the application technical deficiencies. After the September 2021 staff call, LTD submitted another revised technical description in November 2021, but that revised version still indicated that it applied to Arkansas, Louisiana, and Mississippi, and it was still insufficient to show that LTD could meet the obligations associated with its winning bids. Repeated contacts with LTD through March 2022 did not elicit additional financial or technical filings. To conclude this process, staff sent a formal letter to LTD on May 26, 2022, extensively detailing the application’s deficiencies and providing LTD a final opportunity to demonstrate its qualifications for support. LTD’s response was due by June 27, 2022.

In response to that letter, on June 27, 2022, LTD submitted revised financial and technical attachments to explain its network deployment plans in 10 states (Colorado, Illinois, Indiana, Minnesota, Missouri, North Dakota, Ohio, South Dakota, Texas, and Wisconsin). Furthermore, LTD identified that it had entered into two financial agreements on that same day to obtain additional funding and a source for future loaned funds, ostensibly to enhance its financial position and operational

capabilities. Subsequently, staff sought clarification from LTD as to why a technical or financial plan for Nebraska was not included in these revised materials. LTD responded that it was still seeking RDOF support in Nebraska despite not including this state in its final financial and technical submissions.32 In sum, LTD proposed to deploy fiber to 475,616 estimated locations in 11 states.33

The Bureau concluded its review of LTD’s long-form application in each remaining state in which LTD had placed winning bids to determine whether it met all legal, financial, and technical requirements. The Bureau determined that LTD was not reasonably capable of complying with the Commission’s public interest requirements established for the RDOF program for a number of both financial and technical reasons. It therefore denied LTD’s application and announced LTD in default in

all of its remaining winning bids.34 The Bureau also dismissed LTD’s remaining Petition for Reconsideration regarding its ETC Designation Waiver Requests as to Nebraska and North Dakota.35 Having inadvertently failed to dismiss LTD’s ETC Designation Waiver Request in South Dakota when it denied LTD’s long-form application, the Bureau subsequently dismissed that waiver request in a Public Notice.36

Folks in Minnesota have been watching the situation with LTD Broadband with the FCC and the Minnesota PUC, where they have been having similar issues. The MN PUC suspended LTD’s ETC designation in November and asked the Office of Administration to look further into it.

 

New FCC rules protect against discrimination and redlining

St Paul Pioneer Press reports…

The Federal Communications Commission has enacted new rules intended to eliminate discrimination in access to internet services, a move which regulators are calling the first major U.S. digital civil rights policy.

The rules package, which the commission ratified on Wednesday, would empower the agency to review and investigate instances of discrimination by broadband providers to different communities based on income, race, ethnicity and other protected classes.

The order also provides a framework for the FCC to crack down a range of digital inequities including the disparities in the investment of services for different neighborhoods, as well as the “digital divide,” a term experts use to describe the complete lack of internet access many communities experience due to regional or socioeconomic inequality.

The FCC is starting to look at new definitions of broadband

The FCC reports…

The Federal Communications Commission today announced it will launch an inquiry to kick off the agency’s evaluation of the state of broadband across the country, as required by section 706 of the Telecommunications Act of 1996.  As part of this inquiry, the Commission will focus on the universal service goals of section 706—universal deployment, affordability, adoption, availability, and equitable access to broadband throughout the United States.

“During the pandemic and even before it, the needs of internet users surpassed the FCC’s 25/3 standard for broadband.  This standard is not only outdated, it masks the extent to which low-income neighborhoods and rural communities are being left offline and left behind,” said Chairwoman Rosenworcel.  “In order to get big things done, it is essential to set big goals.  That is why we are kicking off this inquiry to update our national broadband standard and also set a long-term goal for gigabit speeds.”

In light of the increasing uses and demands for broadband and the Congressional directives embodied in the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, which includes the largest ever federal investment in broadband deployment, this Notice of Inquiry (NOI) will take a fresh look at the Commission’s standards for evaluating broadband deployment and availability, the quality of the Commission’s available data, and the framework that the agency uses to make a finding under section 706.

In addition to focusing on a universal service standard, the NOI proposes to increase the national fixed broadband speed benchmark to 100 megabits per second for download and 20 megabits per second for upload, and discusses a range of evidence supporting this standard. The FCC previously set the benchmark at 25/3 Mbps in 2015 and has not updated it since.  The NOI also seeks comment on setting a separate national goal of 1 Gbps/500 Mbps for the future.

Lastly, this inquiry will be the first to use the new Broadband Data Collection (BDC) data.  In March 2020, Congress passed the Broadband DATA Act, which required the Commission to collect biannual data relating to the availability and quality of service of fixed and mobile broadband Internet access service for the Commission to create broadband coverage maps.  Pursuant to the Act, the FCC now collects more precise, location-by-location broadband availability data through the BDC.  Through this inquiry, the Commission will examine how these improvements to our data collection may impact the standards and inform the agency’s conclusions about broadband availability.

More info on 22 Companies accepting Enhanced A-CAM funds in Minnesota

The FCC reports…

Consistent with the Commission’s Enhanced A-CAM Order, the Wireline Competition Bureau (Bureau) authorizes 368 rate-of-return companies that elected offers of Enhanced Alternative Connect America Cost Model (Enhanced A-CAM) support to receive model-based support.[1]  Authorization Report 1, released today, shows the authorization amount and initial deployment obligations for each carrier that elected an offer.[2]  The authorizations specify support to the electing companies for a 15-year period beginning January 1, 2024, in exchange for these companies committing to deploy broadband service of at least 100/20 Mbps service to over 700,000 unserved locations across the United States, and maintain or improve existing 100/20 Mbps service to approximately 2 million locations.

Below are the companies serving Minnesota. This list is slightly different than the list I shared earlier in October. Rural Communications Holding Corporation was not on that list.

Holding Company Current Funding  Required Locations Carrier-Served Locations  
 
  ACAM and ACAM II Subtotal                  398,975                            989,720
  CAF BLS Subtotal                    54,054                            510,995
  Total                  453,029                         1,500,715
Albany Mutual Telephone Association ACAM                          26                               3,831
Alliance Communications Cooperative, Inc. ACAM                          29                                  693
Arvig Enterprises, Inc. ACAM                    20,621                             50,966
Benton Cooperative Telephone Company ACAM                          11                               5,826
Rural Communications Holding Corporation ACAM                      1,542                             17,885
Consolidated Telephone Company BLS                          26                             13,656
Emily Cooperative Telephone Company BLS                             –                               2,556
Garden Valley Telephone Company ACAM                         227                             17,786
Gardonville Cooperative Telephone Association ACAM                      1,732                               2,039
Halstad Telephone Company ACAM                             –                               1,629
Harmony Telephone Company ACAM                         460                                  535
Johnson Telephone Company ACAM                         424                               2,842
Kasson & Mantorville Telephone Company ACAM                         116                               4,974
Manchester-Hartland Telephone Company BLS                             –                                  630
Park Region Mutual Telephone Company ACAM                      1,255                               5,032
Paul Bunyan Rural Telephone Cooperative ACAM                         163                             15,617
Spring Grove Communications ACAM                            4                               1,359
Telephone & Data Systems, incl. UScellular ACAM                    11,044                             10,975
Upsala Cooperative Telephone Association ACAM                            2                               1,208
West Central Telephone Assn. ACAM                             –                               5,529
Wikstrom Telephone Company, Inc. ACAM                      1,155                               8,475
Tri-Co Technologies, LLC BLS                         494                               2,964

 

EVENT Nov 15: FCC Will Vote on Rules to Prevent and Eliminate Digital Discrimination

On November 15, the will vote on rules to prevent and eliminate digital discrimination. The FCC has created an easy Fact Sheet and a more complete version for more information. Here’s the overview from that sheet…

Chairwoman Rosenworcel is proposing final rules to prevent discrimination in access to broadband services based on income level, race, ethnicity, color, religion, and national origin. Under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Act, the FCC is required to take steps to ensure that all
Americans have equal access to broadband services and without discrimination based on the characteristics listed in the statute.

And here is how it could help consumers…

Under these rules, the FCC could protect consumers by:

  • Directly addressing companies’ policies and practices if they differentially impact
    consumers’ access to broadband internet access service or are intended to do so;
  • Apply these protections to ensure communities see equitable broadband deployment, network upgrades, and maintenance;
  • Investigate possible instances of discrimination of broadband access, work to solve and – when necessary – penalize companies for failing to meet the obligations defined in the rules;
  • Review consumer complaints of digital discrimination through an improved consumer complaint portal;
  • Help protect both current and prospective subscribers to a broadband internet service.

21 MN broadband providers accept Enhanced A-CAM funding

The FCC has announced providers who have accepted E-ACAM support, which means more time and money to build to broadband at speeds of 100/20 rather than the old A-CAM goal of 25/3…

Today, the Wireline Competition Bureau (Bureau) announces carriers that have accepted offers of model-based Enhanced Alternative Connect America Cost Model (A-CAM) support.

Here are the providers that accepted in Minnesota (name followed by current funding mechanism):

  • Albany Mutual Telephone Association      ACAM
  • Alliance Communications Cooperative, Inc            ACAM
  • Arvig Enterprises, Inc.     ACAM
  • Benton Cooperative Telephone Company               ACAM
  • Consolidated Telephone Company            BLS
  • Emily Cooperative Telephone Company   BLS
  • Garden Valley Telephone Company           ACAM
  • Gardonville Cooperative Telephone Association    ACAM
  • Halstad Telephone Company        ACAM
  • Harmony Telephone Company     ACAM
  • Johnson Telephone Company      ACAM
  • Kasson & Mantorville Telephone Company            ACAM
  • Manchester-Hartland Telephone                BLS
  • Park Region Mutual Telephone Company of Minnesota     ACAM
  • Paul Bunyan Rural Telephone Cooperative             ACAM
  • Spring Grove Communications     ACAM
  • Telephone & Data Systems, incl. UScellular            ACAM
  • Upsala Cooperative Telephone Association            ACAM
  • West Central Telephone Assn.     ACAM
  • Wikstrom Telephone Company, Inc.         ACAM
  • Tri-Co Technologies, LLC BLS

The FCC adds…

Confirmation of receipt of a carrier’s election letter and inclusion on this list does not constitute authorization to receive Enhanced A-CAM support pursuant to the terms of the offer.  Carriers electing Enhanced A-CAM support will not begin receiving such support until the Bureau issues a public notice authorizing the Universal Service Administrative Company (USAC) to disburse the appropriate amounts.  The Commission is publishing this list of carriers that have accepted Enhanced A-CAM “to inform, among other processes, the BEAD Program challenges conducted by states or eligible entities and prevent any duplication of support to a location where it is determined that the Enhanced A-CAM service provider plans to deploy a technology that would satisfy the requirements for being deemed an enforceable commitment for the deployment of qualifying broadband to a location.”

They add…

We note that based on the election letters received, the number of acceptances has exceeded the participation threshold set by the Commission in the Enhanced A-CAM Order.

Here’s more information on Enhanced A-CAM and BEAD from Cost Quest…

The primary purpose of Enhanced A-CAM is to synchronize study areas with the Broadband, Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program funding initiatives. This alignment is aimed at preventing redundant funding efforts and potential strategic manipulation within the same geographical zones.

There are two ways Enhanced ACAM aligns with the NTIA BEAD funding program:

  • The locations are based on Version 2 (V2) of the National Broadband Map to align with the locations under the BEAD program.
  • The timeline is the same as outlined by the NTIA for BEAD locations – 4 years.

The eligible Enhanced ACAM areas will be excluded from BEAD eligibility due to their receipt of Enhanced A-CAM funding. This alteration is anticipated to enhance the efficacy of BEAD funds in expanding coverage. Telecom analyst Mike Conlow highlights, “If all ISPs accept the Enhanced A-CAM offer and build fiber, cable, or licensed fixed wireless, that takes 582,675 locations off the board for the BEAD program,” (Mike Conlow’s Newsletter).

Minnesota schools receive Emergency Connectivity Funding from the FCC

The FCC reports…

The Federal Communications Commission today announced it is committing over $40.8 million in a new funding round through the Emergency Connectivity Fund Program, which provides digital tools and services to support students in communities across the country.  Today’s funding commitment supports applications from the third application window, benefitting approximately 110,000 students nationwide, including students in Georgia, Illinois, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, Oklahoma, Utah, and Washington. …

Today’s announcement will support approximately 220 schools and school districts, 7 libraries and library systems, and 3 consortia.  The funding can be used to support off-campus learning, such as nightly homework, and online learning programs to ensure students across the country have the necessary support to keep up with their education.  More details about which schools and libraries have received funding commitments can be found at https://www.fcc.gov/emergency-connectivity-fund.

Launched in 2021, the Emergency Connectivity Fund Program has provided schools and libraries three different “application windows” to apply for support.  Approximately $6.99 billion in funding commitments have been approved to date, approximately $4.14 billion is supporting applications from Window 1; $834 million from Window 2; and $2.02 billion from Window 3.  To date, the funding has provided support to over 18 million students, 11,300 schools, 1,060 libraries, and 120 consortia, and provided nearly 13 million connected devices and over 8 million broadband connections.

The following organization in Minnesota got funding:

  • KASSON-MANTORVILLE DIST 204
    • School District
    • KASSON
  • STEWARTVILLE SCHOOL DIST 534
    • School District
    • STEWARTVILLE
  • Three Rivers Community Action Head Start
    • School
    • ZUMBROTA
  • PIM Arts High School
    • School District
    • EDEN PRAIRIE
  • ROSEVILLE AREA SCHOOL DIST 623
    • School District
    • ROSEVILLE
  • MAHTOMEDI SCHOOL DISTRICT 832
    • School District
    • MAHTOMEDI
  • MATH AND SCIENCE ACADEMY
    • School
    • WOODBURY
  • SPRING LAKE PK IND SCH DIST 16
    • School District
    • SPRING LAKE PARK
  • ST HELENA CATHOLIC SCHOOL
    • School
    • MINNEAPOLIS
  • MINNEHAHA ACADEMY NORTH
    • School
    • MINNEAPOLIS
  • WATERTOWN-MAYER SCH DIST 111
    • School District
    • WATERTOWN
  • SARTELL – ST STEPHEN INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT 748
    • School District
    • SARTELL
  • HERMANTOWN SCHOOL DISTRICT 700
    • School District
    • HERMANTOWN
  • ESKO PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT 99
    • School District
    • ESKO

 

The US Senate confirms Anna Gomez to FCC

CNBC reports…

  • The Senate voted to confirm Democrat Anna Gomez to the Federal Communications Commission, breaking the deadlock at the agency that has lasted the entirety of the Biden presidency.
  • Gomez’s confirmation comes after a protracted battle to confirm Biden’s initial pick for the commissioner seat, Gigi Sohn, ended with her withdrawal.
  • With the arrival of Gomez, a telecom attorney who’s previously worked in several positions at the FCC and in the private sector, the agency has the opportunity to pursue actions that don’t have the support of the Republican commissioners.

FCC Acts to Provide Subsidy for Consumers in Certain High-Cost Areas

The FCC reports…

The Federal Communications Commission today adopted an order to provide an up-to-$75 monthly broadband benefit for subscribers living in qualifying high-cost areas through the Affordable Connectivity Program (ACP), as directed by the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (Infrastructure Act).  The Infrastructure Act specified that the $75 monthly benefit would support providers that can demonstrate that the standard $30 monthly benefit would cause them to experience “particularized economic hardship” such that they would be unable to maintain part or all of their broadband network in a high-cost area.  Congress separately directed the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA), in consultation with the Commission, to identify the high-cost areas that would be eligible for the enhanced ACP high-cost area benefit.

The Report and Order is expected to incentivize providers to participate in the ACP or remain in the ACP in rural and insular areas, further narrowing the digital divide.  The high-cost area benefit supports other federal initiatives, including those in the Infrastructure Act, to spur deployment and adoption in rural areas by strengthening the business case for providers to deploy broadband in rural and insular areas.

Some RDOF awardees want more money or an out

Ars Technica reports on RDOF winners who are asking for more money or an out…

A group of Internet service providers that won government grants are asking the Federal Communication Commission for more money or an “amnesty window” in which they could give up grants without penalty.

The ISPs were awarded grants to build broadband networks from the FCC’s Rural Digital Opportunity Fund (RDOF), which selected funding recipients in December 2020. A group calling itself the “Coalition of RDOF Winners” has been meeting with FCC officials about their requests for more money or an amnesty window, according to several filings submitted to the commission.

The group says broadband construction costs have soared since the grants were announced. They asked for extra money, quicker payments, relief from letter of credit requirements, or an amnesty window “that allows RDOF winners to relinquish all or part of their RDOF winning areas without forfeitures or other penalties if the Commission chooses not to make supplemental funds available or if the amount of supplemental funds the Commission does make available does not cover an RDOF Winner’s costs that exceed reasonable inflation,” a July 31 filing said.

A different group of ISPs urged the FCC to reject the request, saying that telcos that win grants by pledging to build networks at a low cost are “gaming” the system by seeking more money afterward.

So far, the FCC leadership seems reluctant to provide extra funding. The commission could issue fines to ISPs that default on grants—the FCC recently proposed $8.8 million in fines against 22 RDOF applicants for defaults.

The members of the coalition are unknown. In Minnesota, folks who watch broadband issues will remember that LTD Broadband was initially awarded the opportunity to apply for $1.3 billion but in the end, the FCC did not authorize the grants. During the time when LTD has been awarded the opportunity and was then not given the award many Minnesota communities were stuck in a limbo, unable to apply for other funding and often not certain about the future of LTD Broadband. Sounds like other communities mayb be in a similar position.

FCC gives tribal libraries greater access to E-Rate funding

The FCC announces…

The Federal Communications Commission today adopted an order providing Tribal libraries and other E-Rate participants enhanced access to funding so they can obtain affordable, high-speed broadband services and equipment to connect students and library patrons with online learning opportunities.

More details…

With the Order and Further Notice of Proposed Rulemaking adopted today, the Commission makes changes to provide Tribal communities and other E-Rate participants with greater access to the E-Rate program.  Specific updates to the E-Rate program rules include:

  • Granting E-Rate eligibility to Tribal College and University libraries that serve as public libraries in their communities.

  • Creating an exemption to the competitive bidding requirements for libraries seeking E-Rate support for category two services that total a pre-discount price of $3,600 or less per library per funding year.  Category two services are the internal connections needed for broadband connectivity within schools.  This step can help simplify the application process.

  • Increasing the maximum category two discount rate to 90% and the category two funding floor to $55,000 for Tribal libraries.  This step can raise the amount of funding for category two services that are reimbursable through the E-Rate program.

  • Providing guidance on cost allocation issues experienced by applicants.

  • Adopting a formal definition of “Tribal” within the E-Rate program to better identify Tribal applicants seeking E-Rate funding.

  • Amending the Commission’s E-Rate program rules to add a Tribal community representative to the Universal Service Administrative Company (USAC) Board of Directors.

  • Directing USAC to provide increased outreach and training to Tribal applicants.

  • Seeking comment on ways to further simplify the E-Rate program for all applicants.