Minnesota ranks #7 for broadband

US News and World Report recently release their Best State Rankings. Drum roll please – Minnesota came in second place, behind Iowa.

They looked at 8 areas; here’s how Minnesota ranked:

  • Health Care #7
  • Education #13
  • Economy #20
  • Opportunity #3
  • Infrastructure #6
  • Crime & Corrections #11
  • Fiscal Stability #24
  • Quality of Life #2

Digging into the Infrastructure for Minnesota, here’s how we rank:

  • Internet #7
  • Broadband Access (households download speeds of 25 Mbps or faster)  #10
  • Ultra-Fast Internet Access (households with at least a gig) #14

Senate Committee on Jobs and Economic Growth Finance and Policy gets Broadband Update March 5

Here’s the latest from the Committee on Jobs and Economic Growth Finance and Policy…

Monday, March 5, 2018 – 1:00 PM

Committee on Jobs and Economic Growth Finance and Policy
Chair: Sen. Jeremy R. Miller
1 p.m.
Room 1150 Minnesota Senate Bldg.

Agenda:
Update on Broadband

Update on Workforce Training Programs from Minnesota Department of Labor
and Industry and Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic
Development

I will plan to attend, livestream and take notes.

Small Cell Discussion at Feb 27: House Job Growth and Energy Affordability Policy and Finance Committee

I attended the House Job Growth and Energy Affordability Policy and Finance Committee meeting today – at least to hear the discussion on small cell policy and deployment by AT&T. The presentation is similar to what the Broadband Task Force heard earlier this month.

I think the questions asked by legislators are as informative as the presentation by Paul Weirtz from AT&T.

Notes: Continue reading

Trump’s Take on Federal Funding for Rural Broadband

Late Last week, the White House put out a statement on broadband funding and President Trump’s infrastructure plan. The bad news – there’s not money specifically set aside for broadband; the good news – states are welcome to spend their money on broadband…

WHAT: The President’s Infrastructure Initiative will provide critical funding to help improve broadband access across rural America.

Last week, the President released the details of his infrastructure plan which will provide Federal funding to help repair and modernize rural infrastructure, including broadband. The President’s plan dedicates $50 billion to rural infrastructure, accounting for 25 percent of all Federal spending in the plan. These funds will be awarded directly to the states, giving them the flexibility they need to address their individual rural infrastructure needs.

Under the President’s plan, states will have flexibility to spend as much as 100 percent of the Federal funding they receive on improving rural broadband access. This funding boost will build off of actions the President has already taken to provide more Americans with broadband access in rural areas, such as the Executive Order on “Streamlining and Expediting Requests to Locate Broadband Facilities in Rural America.”

WHY: Expanding broadband access will build a stronger rural America.

Too many rural Americans still don’t have sufficient broadband access. Rural communities have been left behind as high deployment costs have held back internet providers from installing equipment.  In 2016, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) estimated that 23 million rural Americans lack access to sufficient broadband.

Inadequate broadband access is a barrier to rural prosperity. It stunts economic growth and prevents many rural Americans from engaging in the modern economy. Further, lack of broadband access deprives many rural students of educational opportunities afforded to those living in areas with better connectivity.

Expanded broadband access will offer a better quality of life and more economic opportunity for rural communities that have been left behind for too long.

I think it bodes well in Minnesota that we have an Office of Broadband Development ready to manage any funding. I suspect states without an agency or department focused on broadband will have harder time both making the case for spending infrastructure on broadband and just going through the logistics of spending that money.

Minnesota version of Net Neutrality (HF 3033) introduced in the Legislature

The Bill was introduced today (Feb 26)…

Thissen; Ecklund; Metsa; Pryor; Olson; Fischer; Pinto; Freiberg; Flanagan; Carlson, A.; Lee; Davnie; Becker-Finn; Kunesh-Podein; Maye Quade; Sauke; Schultz; Loeffler; Koegel; Considine; Omar; Mahoney; Moran and Lien introduced:

  1. F. 3033,A bill for an act relating to broadband service; prohibiting certain activities by Internet service providers serving Minnesota customers and those under contract to the state or political subdivisions; proposing coding for new law in Minnesota Statutes, chapters 16C; 325F.
    The bill was read for the first time and referred to the Committee on Commerce and Regulatory Reform.

I think it’s fair to call this a Minnesota version of Net Neutrality. You can find the whole proposed bill online – here’s an excerpt…

Sec. 2.

[325F.6945] INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDERS; PROHIBITED ACTIONS.

Subdivision 1.

Definitions. 

The definitions in section 16C.37 apply to this section.

Subd. 2.

Prohibited actions. 

An Internet service provider is prohibited from engaging
in any of the following activities with respect to any of its Minnesota customers:

(1) block lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices, subject to
reasonable network management;

(2) impair, impede, or degrade lawful Internet traffic on the basis of (i) Internet content,
application, or service, or (ii) use of a nonharmful device, subject to reasonable network
management;

(3) engage in paid prioritization;

(4) unreasonably interfere with or unreasonably disadvantage:

(i) a customer’s ability to select, access, and use broadband Internet service or lawful
Internet content, applications, services, or devices of the customer’s choice; or

(ii) an edge provider’s ability to provide lawful Internet content, applications, services,
or devices to a customer; or

(5) engage in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment
of Internet traffic or content.

Subd. 3.

Certification required. 

Prior to offering service to a customer in this state, an
Internet service provider must file with the commissioner of commerce a document certifying,
under penalty of perjury, that it will not engage in any of the activities prohibited in
subdivision 2.

Broadband at the MN Leg Feb 27: House Job Growth and Energy Affordability Policy and Finance Committee

I suspect broadband will come up in the Small Cell discussion. I will plan to attend to take notes and livestream if I can.

Committee Meeting Notice

To:

HOUSE INFORMATION, 175 STATE OFFICE BUILDING
Mike Cook (296-1341)

From:

Adam Seidel, (296-1544)


Committee:

Job Growth and Energy Affordability Policy and Finance


Date/Time/Location:

Tuesday, February 27, 2018
3:00 PM to 4:00 PM
10 State Office Building


Committee Chair:

Rep. Pat Garofalo


Agenda:

Review of Results of 2017 Session:

Exodus Lending, 2017 Jobs Grantee
Sara Nelson-Pallmeyer, Executive Director

Small Cell Installation Reform and Private Investment
Paul Weirtz, President, AT&T Minnesota

Review of Twin home Construction Trends
Nick Erickson, Regulatory Affairs Manager, Builders Association of the Twin Cities

Ramsey/Washington Recycling and Energy Center
Nick Riley, Intergovernmental Relations, Ramsey County

Nominate someone for a Charles Benton Digital Equity Champion Award

OK – let’s get some rural Minnesota names in the hopper…

2018 CHARLES BENTON DIGITAL EQUITY CHAMPION AWARD
The third Charles Benton Digital Equity Champion Award is officially open for nominations! The award will be presented in April at Net Inclusion 2018 in Cleveland, Ohio by the National Digital Inclusion Alliance (NDIA).
Do you know someone who has been a champion of digital equity? Potential nominees could either be long time veterans of the digital inclusion field, or new and passionate supporters of digital skills for all. Nationally focused or locally based – We are looking for everyone making difference!
Please circulate widely. For more information, visit digitalinclusion.org/benton18
Deadline March 28

Digital literacy and older Adults Webinar Archive

Thanks to everyone who attended the webinar last week. I wanted to share the notes, video archive, PowerPoint and a hand out, Connecting Rural Older Americans with Technology: Lessons from Senior Planet

In this webinar, participants will be introduced to OATS & Senior Planet programs, methodology, and the technologies best suited for digital literacy instruction among older learners. Additional topics will cover the impacts of ageism and technology acceptance among older adults, creating social learning environments poised for successful tech adoption, and the implications for deploying digital literacy training in myriad settings.  Finally, participants will be presented with opportunities to discuss replications of OATS programs in their respective catchment areas.

And a big thanks to the presenter:

Alexander Glazebrook, MSW
Director of Training & Technology
Older Adults Technology Services (OATS)
Senior Planet
aglazebrook@oats.org
917 620 9460 cell
168 7th Street, Suite 3A
Brooklyn, New York 11215
www.oats.org  |  www.seniorplanet.org

FCC unveils updated broadband map – does it reflect reality in your zip code?

Borrowing from the Benton headlines – here’s the info on FCC’s latest national broadband map

As it works to close the digital divide, the Federal Communications Commission has updated and modernized its National Broadband Map so the map can once again be a key source of broadband deployment information for consumers, policymakers, researchers, and others. The new, cloud-based map will support more frequent data updates and display improvements at a far lower cost than the original mapping platform, which had not been updated in years. Improvements and features in the successor National Broadband Map include:

  • Fixed deployment data based on the latest collection by the FCC and updated twice annually

  • Deployment summaries available for seven different geographical types: nation, state, county, congressional district, city or town (census place), Tribal area, and Core -based

  • Statistical Area (such as New York-Newark-Jersey City NY-NJ-PA)

  • Broadband availability and provider counts in each of the nation’s over 11 million census blocks, available for six technologies (fiber, DSL, cable, satellite, fixed wireless, and other) as well as seven speeds, for a total of 441 combinations

  • Provider summary information available for 1,782 providers by technology, eight download speed tiers, and nine upload speed tiers

  • Deployment comparisons between geographic areas

  • A portal for data downloads

  • Satellite imagery map overlay that shows buildings, roads, and geography

  • Graphs that show what fraction of an area’s population has access to broadband at a given speed

You can use the maps to track access to a specific address or by community – county, state, zip code, tribal area, congressional district or MSA. Rumor has it that FCC Commissioner Jessica Rosenworcel is encouraging people to send corrections/suggestions to broadbandfail@fcc.gov. SO check it out – see if what you find on the maps for your community meets what you know to be true. If not, report it. These maps are used to make decisions. It’s worth making sure they are as accurate as possible.

Senator Klobuchar suggests Social Media sites get rid of bots or get fined

According to MSN News

Social media giants Facebook Inc. and Twitter Inc. should be fined if they don’t weed out automated accounts, or bots, trying to influence U.S. public opinion, said Democratic Senator Amy Klobuchar.

“I think that would be a great idea,” Klobuchar, of Minnesota, said on NBC’s “Meet the Press” on Sunday when asked whether the companies should face fines if they fail to act after the government discovers the bots.

The comments come after the Justice Department on Feb. 16 indicted Russians associated with the Internet Research Agency, a Russian organization it said “had a strategic goal to sow discord in the U.S. political system” including during the 2016 presidential election. The organization conducted operations on YouTube Inc., a unit of Google Inc., Facebook and its subsidiary Instagram, and Twitter, according to the indictment.

Even though Klobuchar said fining the social media companies is desirable, she was skeptical it would happen. “You need a Congress to act, and there are too many people that are afraid of doing something about this because we know these sites are popular,”’ she said.

Klobuchar, a member of the Senate Judiciary Committee and top Democrat on a subcommittee that deals with antitrust and consumer rights issues, has introduced bipartisan legislation that would require social media companies to disclose who is paying for online adds.

Emily Cooperative Telephone Company Selects Calix AXOS to Deliver Always-On Gigabit Services in Central Minnesota

For the practitioners in the crowd, I’m going to share part of Calix’s press release on Emily Cooperative Telephone using their products..

Calix, Inc. (NYSE:CALX) today announced Emily Cooperative Telephone Company (ECTC) is deploying the Calix AXOS E7-2 Intelligent Modular System and GigaFamily premises solutions for their next generation fiber network in Central Minnesota. An NTCA Gig-Certified service provider, ECTC will upgrade their existing GPON and Active Ethernet based network to Calix AXOS GPON solutions in order to deliver a sensational subscriber experience to their customers. With the always-on, self-healing, and remote diagnostic capabilities enabled by AXOS, ECTC can streamline operations and minimize downtime for maintenance windows and repairs, dramatically reducing operating costs. More importantly, these powerful and unique AXOS features also are increasingly valuable to subscribers, driving lower churn, and higher customer satisfaction.

“As ECTC looked ahead to the transformation of our fiber network, we were looking not just for another box, but for a platform that could evolve with us as we move to software defined access and next generation fiber technologies,” said Josh Netland, general manager at ECTC. “That is exactly what we have found in Calix, a partner who is committed to that transformation as well. Calix has a compelling vision both for the future of our network, driven by AXOS, but also for our services, including smart home and Carrier Class Wi-Fi offerings. We feel confident that we are moving forward with the right partner who will help us maximize our long-term investment and allow us to bring a world-class broadband experience to our subscribers.”

And a little on ECTC…

Emily Cooperative Telephone Company (ECTC) is proud to offer the Central Minnesota communities of Emily, Fifty Lakes, Little Pine and Fairfield Townships the highest internet speeds, the latest in high definition digital television technology and premium telephone services. Through our ultra-fast, ultra-reliable fiber optic network, we provide our customers with state-of-the-art technology and customer service that’s second to none.

Rural Mower County MN homes could get access to high-speed internet

Austin Daily Herald reports…

Nearly 17,500 rural homes and businesses in Minnesota, including over 500 in Mower County, that are currently unserved by high-speed Internet service could get connectivity in the near future.

These homes and businesses are in unserved areas of Minnesota and are eligible for financial support from the next phase of FCC’s Connect America Fund (CAF), which helps offset the high cost of extending broadband service into rural areas. The FCC will be distributing these funds through an innovative “reverse auction,” which is scheduled to launch on July 24.

That includes 527 eligible sites in Mower County, 96 in Dodge and 143 in Steele County.

The auction is open to a wide range of broadband providers. Applications will be judged on a number of factors – including speeds available. Faster speeds are  weighted differently than slower speeds. Here’s a break down from the FCC

As the Herald points out, parts of Mower County are eligible. That doesn’t mean that there’s a provider ready to make a bid – but it means it’s possible.

Rep Garofalo introduces changes to MN broadband grant program – removes “unserved” from grant program language

On Thursday (Feb 22), Representative Garofalo introduced

  1. F. No. 3002, A bill for an act relating to broadband; modifying eligibility for the border-to-border broadband grant program; amending Minnesota Statutes 2016, sections 116J.39, subdivision 4; 116J.394; 116J.395, subdivisions 1, 5, 6. The bill was read for the first time and referred to the Committee on Job Growth and Energy Affordability Policy and Finance.

You can see the proposed changes online; it impacts the eligibility for the border-to-border broadband grant program.

Here are the proposed changes:

Remove “unserved areas” from the definition by removing the following:

(start line 3.15) (i) “Unserved areas” means areas of Minnesota in which households or businesses lack 
access to wire-line broadband service, as defined in section 116J.39.

And remove the term/idea from the following (I’ll make the deleted terms bold below):

(start line 3.19) A grant program is established under the Department of
Employment and Economic Development to award grants to eligible applicants in order to
promote the expansion of access to broadband service in unserved or underserved areas of
the state.

 

(start line 3.25) An applicant for a grant under this section shall provide
the following information on the application:

(1) the location of the project;

(2) the kind and amount of broadband infrastructure to be purchased for the project;

(3) evidence regarding the unserved or underserved nature of the community in which
the project is to be located;

 

(start line 4.18) Subd. 6.

Awarding grants.

(a) In evaluating applications and awarding grants, the
commissioner shall give priority to applications that are constructed in areas identified by
the director of the Office of Broadband Development as unserved.

Added at 2 pm:

Gulp – I just realized I missed one change:
(starting line 3.12) In the definition second of Underserved – “wireline” is removed:
“Underserved areas” means areas of Minnesota in which households or businesses
lack access to wire-line broadband service at speeds of at least 100 megabits per second
download and at least 20 megabits per second upload.

That is important too. The MN Broadband Task Force has been hearing from wireless providers lately.

Federal Government has $20 billion for infrastructure – is Minnesota poised to make the most of it?

Doug Dawson of CCG reports

There is a lot of speculation that we might be seeing some money aimed at broadband due to the budget passed by Congress on February 9. That bill contains $20 billion for infrastructure spending spread evenly in fiscal years 2018 and 2019. On a floor speech as part of the vote, Senate Majority Leader Charles Schumer says the money will go towards “existing projects for water and energy infrastructure as well as expanding broadband to rural regions and improving surface transportation”.

Any broadband money that comes out of this funding will have to be spent quickly by the government. The fiscal year 2018 is already almost half over and ends on September 30 of this year. It’s likely that any grants coming out of such money would have to awarded before that September date to count as spending in this fiscal year. In order to move that fast I’m guessing the government is going to have to take shortcuts and use processes already in place. That probably means using the BTOP grant forms and processes again.

The short time frame for any of this funding also likely means that only ‘shovel-ready’ projects will be considered. But that aligns with statements made by the administration last year when talking about infrastructure projects. Anybody hoping to go after such grants better already have an engineered project in mind.

The good news is that many Minnesota communities are ready. To be shovel ready you need to have a plan. Often that means a feasibility study, a marketing study and engineering study. And Minnesota communities are in various stages of preparedness because these are the same tools that prepare a community for the Border to Border grants. It’s an unintended consequence – not only does the State funding help communities (worth noting that so far the Office of Broadband Development has awarded $85M to 112 projects with $110M match!) but we prepare our communities for other opportunities too.

Computers improving quality of life for the disabled and seniors

Thanks for permission from the IRRRB to reprint…

Fifty senior citizens and people with disabilities recently received free computers and computer classes through a technology outreach initiative led by Access North Center for Independent Living. The outreach was part of a larger Blandin Foundation program designed to advance broadband in northeastern Minnesota rural communities.

“Access North solicited applications from our client base, and the response was immediate from folks who did not have a computer or wanted to replace their obsolete home device,” said Don Brunette, Access North executive director.

According to Brunette, the computer classes were taught by Richard Spicer, who is a veteran, computer class instructor and Access North client.

Founded in 1985, Access North serves 10 counties in northeastern Minnesota. Its Hibbing office partnered with Hibbing Area Chamber of Commerce, PCs for People and Blandin on this initiative. Each recipient received a hard drive, monitor, keyboard and mouse from PCs for People. In addition, Access North assisted these citizens with acquiring subsidized home Wi-Fi connection when possible and provided them free printers donated by Target Corporation.

The Blandin Broadband Communities program is supported in part by a grant from Iron Range Resources & Rehabilitation and involves an intensive two-year partnership between Blandin and area communities to advance broadband initiatives. This ongoing effort helps northeastern Minnesota rural communities develop high speed internet that is critical to economic development, education, healthcare and quality of life.

Visit the Access North website.