On February 25, the FCC held a hearing on broadband network management practices. (You can download audio and video of the meeting.) IP Democracy did a nice write up of the meeting. (A big thanks to them for saving me the effort!) The short description – the got together to talk about allegations of Comcast over-managing their network to the disservice of certain applications.
My super short notes – everyone recognized that providers need to be able to manage their networks to keep them running. But we need to know that network management is reasonable – that consumers will be able to do what they want and need to do. (So long as it is legal.) As Rep Markley said – Internet freedoms are consumer-centric.
Another big point was transparency. Consumers need to know the rules as the providers maintain them. As Michael Copps alluded, decisions on how the Internet works (and info flows) are currently being made by providers and other vendors. (He gave some great examples.)
Copps suggested that the FCC create a process for future allegations against broadband providers.
Several speakers mentioned a bill of rights for online citizens.
Gilles BianRosa gives a nice demo of Vuze (a Peer to Peer application) in explaining how traffic throttling by a network provider affects the service. He also estimated that the upload capacity of a US connection is 10-20 percent of the download speed – whereas in the rest of the world upload is generally equal to download.
Comcast votes for letting the market set the rules and encouraging the FCC to tread lightly on regulation.
(You can get a list of upcoming meetings on the FCC site.)
“At the FCC’s hearing in Cambridge, Mass., yesterday, Comcast filled the limited-seating room with hired spectators, according to an Associated Press report…” http://www.cedmagazine.com/Comcast-in-seating-shenanigans-at-FCC-hearing.aspx
That’s the word on the street. To think that was someone’s paid acting debut – and I thought I was having a bad week.
By: Ann Treacy on February 28, 2008
at 3:27 pm
[...] Press Offers ‘Olive Branch’ to Cable) is an update on the Free Press versus Comcast situation. Free Press complained to the FCC that Comcast was throttling traffic of BitTorrent users. After one (I think one) public session with the FCC, [...]
By: Who should build the network in US or UK? « Blandin on Broadband on April 20, 2008
at 9:35 pm