Help crowdsource a benchmark to measure impact of Net Neutrality Repeal

Happy New Year! It’s a good day for looking back and in the broadband world, the topic of 2017 was Net Neutrality. Many are concerned that repeal of Net Neutrality will lead to higher prices for consumers and/or tiered pricing for premium content. Many providers say that they will continue to provide the same level of service they always have; nothing will change to the services or prices as a result of the repeal.

New Year is also a good time to look forward. Set goals. Assess. So I want to propose that instead of stepping on the dreaded scale to set goals – that we all check out broadband prices in our respective areas. That will set a benchmark for us to measure any impact of Net Neutrality.

I started by checking out services in my zip code. I found the list of providers on the Office of Broadband Development interactive broadband map. There are nine providers/services in my area:

  • AT&T (Mobile)
  • CenturyLink DSL
  • CenturyLink (Fiber)
  • Comcast (Cable)
  • Hughes Net (Satellite)
  • Sprint (Mobile)
  • T-Mobile (Mobile)
  • Verizon Wireless (Mobile)
  • ViaSat (Satellite)

Telecom changes will only directly impact CenturyLink but I checked pricing for cable and satellite as well. While I know in some areas, people use mobile option for home access, that would be pretty rare in St Paul so I didn’t check those prices. (That being said, I have a mobile hotspot but not for primary home or business use.)

I tracked the info I could for each services based on information from the provider websites. So, if they didn’t specific up or download speed, I didn’t either. If they mentioned a restriction, so did I. I posted the best deal I could find with minimal research.

Here are the options for my address through CenturyLink:

For Internet Only:

  • Gig – $85/month
  • 100 Mbps – $65/month
  • 40 Mbps – $55/month

Bundle of Internet, phone and TV (basic Prism)

  • Gig – $194.99/month
  • 100 Mbps – $174.99/month
  • 40 Mbps – $164.99/month

Here are the options for my address through Comcast/Xfinity:

For Internet and TV (Channels – I chose fewest channels)

  • 200 Mbps (down) – $69.99/month (with one year agreement)
  • 100 Mbps (down) – $59.99/month (with one year agreement)
  • 55 Mbps (down) – $49.99/month (with one year agreement)

Here are the options for my address through HughesNet:

  • 25 Mbps for 50 GB data – $99.99/month (requires 2 year agreement; if you surpass 10 GB your connection speeds will be reduced)
  • 25 Mbps for 30 GB data – $79.99/month (requires 2 year agreement; if you surpass 10 GB your connection speeds will be reduced)
  • 25 Mbps for 20 GB data – $59.99/month (requires 2 year agreement; if you surpass 10 GB your connection speeds will be reduced)
  • 25 Mbps for 10 GB data – $49.99/month (requires 2 year agreement; if you surpass 10 GB your connection speeds will be reduced)

Here are the options for my address through ViaSat/Exede

  • 30 Mbps (down) for unlimited data – $150/month ($100/month for first 3 months)
  • 25 Mbps (down) for unlimited data – $100/month ($70/month for first 3 months)
  • 12 Mbps (down) for unlimited data – $70/month ($50/month for first 3 months)
  • 12 Mbps (down) for 10 GB – $50/month ($30/month for first 3 months)

BUT on Unlimited service plans, after 150GB of data usage, they may prioritize your data behind other customers during network congestion.

If you want to check your own area and either send me your results atreacy@treaycinfo.com or post them in the comments below that would help create the larger benchmark. You don’t have to check all of the options in your area – just starting with your current provider would be great. Next year we can see how things compare.

This entry was posted in Research, Vendors by Ann Treacy. Bookmark the permalink.

About Ann Treacy

I have a Master’s Degree in Library and Information Science. I have been interested or involved in providing access to information through the Internet since 1994, when I worked for Minnesota’s first Internet service provider. I am pleased to be a part of the Blandin on Broadband Team. I also work with MN Coalition on Government Information, Minnesota Rural Partners, and the American Society for Information Science and Technology.

One thought on “Help crowdsource a benchmark to measure impact of Net Neutrality Repeal

  1. From Mahtomedi:
    $59.99/month/up to 200 Mbps for Comcast
    OR (total bill) Comcast performance plus and 3 phone lines, total price 113.24 /mo including taxes and equipment rental

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s